We really don't permit smoking in the office, so we sent 'Mickey The Crab' out on the street to round-up the collectiveopinion of the 2023 fantasy football community. Despite having generally poor interpersonal skills, Mickey did an admirable job of conversing with most of the fantasy experts he metup with and we are happy to present his findings here in the Top 200 'Man on the Street' Consensus Rankings.
OverallQB OnlyRB OnlyWR OnlyTE OnlyPK OnlyDEF Only

2023 Top 200 Consensus Rankings All Positions -September 07, 2023

Rank Player Team Position Bye
Week
Average
Ranking
Highest
Ranking
Lowest
Ranking
# 1 Justin Jefferson WR 13 1.40 1 3 1
# 2 Ja'Marr Chase WR 7 2.14 1 4 3
# 3 Christian McCaffrey RB 9 2.29 1 3 2
# 4 Austin Ekeler RB 5 4.43 2 7 4
# 5 Tyreek Hill WR 10 4.71 4 6 6
# 6 Bijan Robinson RB 11 8.43 5 12 5
# 7 Travis Kelce TE 10 9.43 6 17 7
# 8 Saquon Barkley RB 13 9.57 6 15 10
# 9 Stefon Diggs WR 13 10.43 7 16 11
# 10 Nick Chubb RB 5 11.00 3 17 8
# 11 Ceedee Lamb WR 7 12.14 8 17 14
# 12 Davante Adams WR 13 13.14 10 15 16
# 13 AJ Brown WR 10 13.43 9 19 13
# 14 Derrick Henry RB 7 13.43 7 18 12
# 15 Tony Pollard RB 7 14.14 8 21 15
# 16 Cooper Kupp WR 10 14.57 4 40 -
# 17 Amon-Ra St-Brown WR 9 15.43 10 20 21
# 18 Garrett Wilson WR 7 16.29 9 22 20
# 19 Josh Jacobs RB 13 17.00 12 22 19
# 20 Jaylen Waddle WR 10 19.86 18 24 22
# 21 Chris Olave WR 11 23.71 19 35 27
# 22 Devonta Smith WR 10 24.43 20 28 30
# 23 Patrick Mahomes QB 10 25.29 20 30 9
# 24 Rhamondre Stevenson RB 11 25.43 14 31 31
# 25 Joe Mixon RB 7 26.43 22 32 23
# 26 Travis Etienne RB 9 27.29 18 36 26
# 27 Jalen Hurts QB 10 27.29 21 34 18
# 28 Josh Allen QB 13 27.71 21 35 17
# 29 Najee Harris RB 6 28.00 23 33 24
# 30 Tee Higgins WR 7 28.43 23 39 34
# 31 Mark Andrews TE 13 29.43 24 36 33
# 32 DK Metcalf WR 5 31.86 25 42 35
# 33 Aaron Jones RB 6 33.57 26 38 32
# 34 Amari Cooper WR 5 34.43 32 41 42
# 35 Calvin Ridley WR 9 36.14 22 49 36
# 36 Keenan Allen WR 5 36.57 29 45 43
# 37 Kenneth Walker RB 5 37.14 20 47 41
# 38 Jahmyr Gibbs RB 9 38.43 32 47 29
# 39 Deebo Samuel WR 9 38.57 30 47 38
# 40 Dameon Pierce RB 7 42.86 35 48 39
# 41 Breece Hall RB 7 43.14 23 53 44
# 42 Joe Burrow QB 7 46.29 39 59 28
# 43 Deandre Hopkins WR 7 46.29 27 56 52
# 44 TJ Hockenson TE 13 47.57 30 59 45
# 45 DJ Moore WR 13 48.71 38 59 49
# 46 Lamar Jackson QB 13 49.57 37 82 25
# 47 JK Dobbins RB 13 50.67 37 68 -
# 48 Drake London WR 11 51.00 39 66 58
# 49 Alexander Mattison RB 13 51.43 37 83 47
# 50 Terry McLaurin WR 14 51.57 40 66 61
# 51 Miles Sanders RB 7 53.29 41 75 50
# 52 Jonathan Taylor RB 11 54.71 10 83 -
# 53 Justin Fields QB 13 55.71 42 67 40
# 54 Cam Akers RB 10 56.14 50 65 56
# 55 Tyler Lockett WR 5 56.14 45 72 62
# 56 Rachaad White RB 5 56.29 38 69 64
# 57 Brandon Aiyuk WR 9 56.57 48 69 60
# 58 Christian Watson WR 6 56.71 40 77 53
# 59 James Conner RB 14 57.43 42 69 54
# 60 Chris Godwin WR 5 61.00 49 78 66
# 61 George Kittle TE 9 62.00 53 78 46
# 62 Mike Williams WR 5 62.00 54 74 68
# 63 Justin Herbert QB 5 62.43 44 82 37
# 64 James Cook RB 13 62.71 47 81 57
# 65 Diontae Johnson WR 6 62.86 50 76 73
# 66 Mike Evans WR 5 63.43 51 77 71
# 67 Darren Waller TE 13 63.86 39 94 51
# 68 Alvin Kamara RB 11 66.71 48 81 -
# 69 David Montgomery RB 9 67.86 58 74 69
# 70 Javonte Williams RB 9 68.29 54 79 63
# 71 Dallas Goedert TE 10 68.71 53 84 55
# 72 Trevor Lawrence QB 9 70.29 56 89 48
# 73 Michael Pittman WR 11 70.43 63 82 87
# 74 Isiah Pacheco RB 10 70.57 61 79 65
# 75 Christian Kirk WR 9 71.14 49 89 70
# 76 D'Andre Swift RB 10 71.57 37 86 75
# 77 Kyle Pitts TE 11 72.43 47 91 59
# 78 Marquise Brown WR 14 74.14 42 83 88
# 79 Dalvin Cook RB 7 74.29 47 88 67
# 80 Jahan Dotson WR 14 78.43 63 98 81
# 81 Jerry Jeudy WR 9 79.00 71 90 77
# 82 George Pickens WR 6 79.29 71 96 74
# 83 Khalil Herbert RB 13 83.14 66 111 79
# 84 Brian Robinson RB 14 84.57 73 112 83
# 85 AJ Dillon RB 6 87.71 77 103 90
# 86 Deshaun Watson QB 5 88.00 70 101 72
# 87 Jordan Addison WR 13 89.29 81 97 85
# 88 Dak Prescott QB 7 90.43 81 101 76
# 89 Courtland Sutton WR 9 90.43 84 104 102
# 90 Antonio Gibson RB 14 91.29 84 101 100
# 91 Gabe Davis WR 13 91.86 76 114 91
# 92 Evan Engram TE 9 92.14 78 111 78
# 93 Brandin Cooks WR 7 92.57 80 107 96
# 94 Pat Freiermuth TE 6 93.00 67 108 84
# 95 Tua Tagovailoa QB 10 94.29 77 102 82
# 96 Jaxon Smith-Njigba WR 5 96.57 88 104 93
# 97 Samaje Perine RB 9 97.43 88 112 109
# 98 Daniel Jones QB 13 98.71 88 110 99
# 99 Jamaal Williams RB 11 98.86 78 108 101
#100 Treylon Burks WR 7 99.57 77 117 122
#101 Raheem Mostert RB 10 102.43 87 121 108
#102 Jerick McKinnon RB 10 104.14 74 125 121
#103 Juju Smith-Schuster WR 11 104.29 88 117 114
#104 Kirk Cousins QB 13 105.57 97 112 86
#105 Michael Thomas WR 11 105.57 86 120 103
#106 Jakobi Meyers WR 13 109.43 95 122 138
#107 Zay Flowers WR 13 110.43 92 132 95
#108 Zach Charbonnet RB 5 111.00 96 154 104
#109 Anthony Richardson QB 11 111.29 90 147 98
#110 Devon Achane RB 10 111.50 102 121 151
#111 Elijah Moore WR 5 111.50 96 147 125
#112 Geno Smith QB 5 113.29 98 128 105
#113 Nico Collins WR 7 115.57 105 136 142
#114 Aaron Rodgers QB 7 115.67 106 124 -
#115 David Njoku TE 5 116.14 91 170 94
#116 Rashaad Penny RB 10 116.14 90 142 115
#117 Kadarius Toney WR 10 120.00 92 153 116
#118 Rashod Bateman WR 13 120.14 103 174 152
#119 De'Von Achane RB 10 120.50 96 131 -
#120 Elijah Mitchell RB 9 122.00 111 143 134
#121 Chigoziem Okonkwo TE 7 123.71 112 130 155
#122 Odell Beckham WR 13 123.86 103 133 107
#123 Skyy Moore WR 10 124.43 100 187 111
#124 Jaylen Warren RB 6 125.43 97 156 133
#125 Dalton Schultz TE 7 126.29 95 159 126
#126 Quentin Johnston WR 5 126.57 107 158 112
#127 Tyler Allgeier RB 11 126.86 110 145 147
#128 Ezekiel Elliott RB 11 127.80 116 138 117
#129 Allen Lazard WR 7 128.00 119 142 148
#130 Dalton Kincaid TE 13 129.33 110 144 106
#131 Damien Harris RB 13 129.57 118 146 140
#132 Jared Goff QB 9 130.29 124 141 113
#133 Devin Singletary RB 7 131.50 107 161 172
#134 Tyler Higbee TE 10 131.71 111 171 135
#135 Russell Wilson QB 9 135.17 119 159 131
#136 Kenneth Gainwell RB 10 137.00 115 190 157
#137 Juwan Johnson TE 11 138.25 122 149 159
#138 Zay Jones WR 9 139.29 115 169 167
#139 Darnell Mooney WR 13 139.33 128 156 183
#140 Rondale Moore WR 14 140.00 106 180 199
#141 Greg Dulcich TE 9 140.71 123 152 165
#142 Cole Kmet TE 13 140.86 105 190 128
#143 Sam Laporta TE 9 142.17 114 162 139
#144 Tyler Boyd WR 7 142.43 133 163 175
#145 Romeo Doubs WR 6 144.57 115 198 156
#146 Marvin Mims WR 9 144.60 129 160 169
#147 Tank Bigsby RB 9 146.00 127 171 137
#148 Adam Thielen WR 7 146.17 124 177 153
#149 Jameson Williams WR 9 148.33 130 174 -
#150 DJ Chark WR 7 150.17 133 189 194
#151 D'Onta Foreman RB 13 152.83 125 176 182
#152 Michael Gallup WR 7 152.86 143 164 197
#153 Matthew Stafford QB 10 153.17 133 183 158
#154 San Francisco 49ers DEF 9 153.60 147 164 80
#155 Donovan Peoples-Jones WR 5 154.50 138 181 226
#156 Brock Purdy QB 9 155.00 141 170 129
#157 Gerald Everett TE 5 155.43 141 173 185
#158 Kenny Pickett QB 6 157.17 140 170 141
#159 Curtis Samuel WR 14 159.17 137 179 267
#160 Roschon Johnson RB 13 159.40 119 199 145
#161 Derek Carr QB 11 159.67 146 178 144
#162 Van Jefferson WR 10 161.00 135 201 205
#163 Dallas Cowboys DEF 7 161.20 150 175 97
#164 Chuba Hubbard RB 7 161.43 130 201 195
#165 Justin Tucker PK 13 161.75 138 173 89
#166 Buffalo Bills DEF 13 165.00 154 177 110
#167 Philadelphia Eagles DEF 10 165.80 153 177 92
#168 Alec Pierce WR 11 166.25 138 188 256
#169 Jonathan Mingo WR 7 166.33 136 195 181
#170 Isaiah Hodgins WR 13 167.60 152 182 224
#171 KJ Osborn WR 13 168.40 135 191 231
#172 Kendre Miller RB 11 168.75 151 197 163
#173 Gus Edwards RB 13 169.00 150 182 200
#174 Marquez Valdes-Scantling WR 10 170.75 129 194 210
#175 Jordan Love QB 6 171.00 150 194 146
#176 Jerome Ford RB 5 172.00 128 227 254
#177 Jake Ferguson TE 7 174.00 136 234 208
#178 Jayden Reed WR 6 174.80 148 212 206
#179 Zack Moss RB 11 175.67 143 211 246
#180 Jalin Hyatt WR 13 176.67 149 203 161
#181 Evan Hull RB 11 176.75 122 218 -
#182 Rashid Shaheed WR 11 177.40 167 187 268
#183 Dawson Knox TE 13 177.83 134 228 177
#184 Irv Smith TE 7 178.00 146 211 196
#185 New York Jets DEF 7 179.60 163 193 119
#186 Joshua Kelley RB 5 180.40 158 205 259
#187 Sam Howell QB 14 181.75 148 218 176
#188 TY Chandler RB 13 182.00 120 206 236
#189 Tyjae Spears RB 7 182.83 155 207 166
#190 Baltimore Ravens DEF 13 183.00 171 191 149
#191 Cordarrelle Patterson RB 11 184.50 127 245 215
#192 New Orleans Saints DEF 11 186.20 162 213 143
#193 Clyde Edwards-Helaire RB 10 186.75 179 196 193
#194 Tyler Bass PK 13 187.00 161 216 127
#195 New England Patriots DEF 11 187.25 177 205 120
#196 Denver Broncos DEF 9 188.00 166 199 180
#197 Daniel Carlson PK 13 188.25 157 223 123
#198 Jeff Wilson RB 10 188.67 126 301 -
#199 Harrison Butker PK 10 188.75 167 203 118
#200 Deon Jackson RB 11 189.00 108 245 198