We really don't permit smoking in the office, so we sent 'Mickey The Crab' out on the street to round-up the collectiveopinion of the 2025 fantasy football community. Despite having generally poor interpersonal skills, Mickey did an admirable job of conversing with most of the fantasy experts he metup with and we are happy to present his findings here in the Top 200 'Man on the Street' Consensus Rankings.
OverallQB OnlyRB OnlyWR OnlyTE OnlyPK OnlyDEF Only
2025 Top 200 Expert Consensus Rankings DEF Only -August 24, 2025

Rank Team Position Bye
Week		 Average
Ranking		 Highest
Ranking		 Lowest
Ranking
# 1 Philadelphia Eagles DEF 9 161.50 119 181 194
# 2 Denver Broncos DEF 12 166.50 136 198 197
# 3 Buffalo Bills DEF 7 168.33 134 201 240
# 4 Baltimore Ravens DEF 7 168.50 143 187 202
# 5 Pittsburgh Steelers DEF 5 168.50 154 182 215
# 6 Houston Texans DEF 6 171.67 149 199 239
# 7 Minnesota Vikings DEF 6 175.17 160 188 247
# 8 Kansas City Chiefs DEF 10 186.00 160 203 316
# 9 Detroit Lions DEF 8 193.50 176 221 280
# 10 New York Jets DEF 9 195.67 166 216 471
# 11 Dallas Cowboys DEF 10 209.20 144 273 288
# 12 Seattle Seahawks DEF 8 232.17 173 430 333
# 13 Chicago Bears DEF 5 242.60 180 291 347
# 14 Los Angeles Rams DEF 8 254.80 178 460 567
# 15 Green Bay Packers DEF 5 255.20 162 449 317
# 16 San Francisco 49ers DEF 14 260.00 169 462 318
# 17 Cleveland Browns DEF 9 268.60 199 435 365
# 18 Los Angeles Chargers DEF 12 276.50 195 433 373
# 19 New England Patriots DEF 14 279.33 175 481 556
# 20 Tampa Bay Buccaneers DEF 9 296.80 202 465 367
# 21 New York Giants DEF 14 300.00 206 436 314
# 22 Indianapolis Colts DEF 11 305.60 179 471 378
# 23 Washington Commanders DEF 12 338.20 227 466 380
# 24 Miami Dolphins DEF 12 346.00 269 472 396
# 25 Atlanta Falcons DEF 5 357.67 188 - 403
# 26 Arizona Cardinals DEF 8 364.67 298 476 370
# 27 Cincinnati Bengals DEF 10 389.33 305 458 349
# 28 New Orleans Saints DEF 11 397.33 262 502 589
# 29 Las Vegas Raiders DEF 8 402.00 264 508 566
# 30 Jacksonville Jaguars DEF 8 404.33 283 501 465