We really don't permit smoking in the office, so we sent 'Mickey The Crab' out on the street to round-up the collectiveopinion of the 2026 fantasy football community. Despite having generally poor interpersonal skills, Mickey did an admirable job of conversing with most of the fantasy experts he metup with and we are happy to present his findings here in the Top 200 'Man on the Street' Consensus Rankings.
OverallQB OnlyRB OnlyWR OnlyTE OnlyPK OnlyDEF Only
2026 Top 200 Expert Consensus Rankings PK Only -September 4, 2026

Rank Team Position Bye
Week		 Average
Ranking		 Highest
Ranking		 Lowest
Ranking
# 1 Brandon Aubrey PK 14 170.71 118 266 131
# 2 Ka'Imi Fairbairn PK 8 200.50 146 300 153
# 3 Cam Little PK 7 210.57 162 296 184
# 4 Cameron Dicker PK 7 211.14 133 298 154
# 5 Jason Myers PK 11 216.00 171 297 162
# 6 Evan McPherson PK 6 221.00 163 257 275
# 7 Jake Bates PK 6 223.83 179 258 204
# 8 Eddy Pineiro PK 8 224.67 169 264 230
# 9 Tyler Loop PK 13 233.67 201 260 240
# 10 Cairo Santos PK 10 244.83 161 299 286
# 11 Fairbairn Ka'Imi PK 8 246.00 246 246 -
# 12 Harrison Butker PK 5 246.20 195 274 212
# 13 Harrison Mevis PK 11 247.00 177 275 200
# 14 Jason Sanders PK 8 249.00 249 249 711
# 15 Andy Borregales PK 11 250.80 213 344 328
# 16 Chase McLaughlin PK 10 251.20 222 281 269
# 17 Chris Boswell PK 9 252.00 223 281 254
# 18 Will Reichard PK 6 259.50 185 341 259
# 19 Jake Moody PK 7 262.00 262 262 632
# 20 Cade York PK 13 263.00 263 263 -
# 21 Wil Lutz PK 10 265.40 192 317 284
# 22 Andre Szmyt PK 11 275.00 275 275 755
# 23 Charlie Smyth PK 8 288.00 221 325 744
# 24 Spencer Shrader PK 13 303.67 236 391 727
# 25 Matt Gay PK 13 312.50 258 367 479
# 26 Trey Smack (R) PK 11 320.50 184 449 205
# 27 Tyler Bass PK 7 322.00 243 447 319
# 28 Jake Elliott PK 10 323.60 235 443 301
# 29 Zane Gonzalez PK . 341.50 282 401 -
# 30 Brandon McManus PK . 356.50 279 434 -