We really don't permit smoking in the office, so we sent 'Mickey The Crab' out on the street to round-up the collectiveopinion of the 2025 fantasy football community. Despite having generally poor interpersonal skills, Mickey did an admirable job of conversing with most of the fantasy experts he metup with and we are happy to present his findings here in the Top 200 'Man on the Street' Consensus Rankings.
OverallQB OnlyRB OnlyWR OnlyTE OnlyPK OnlyDEF Only
2025 Top 200 Expert Consensus Rankings PK Only -August 24, 2025

Rank Team Position Bye
Week		 Average
Ranking		 Highest
Ranking		 Lowest
Ranking
# 1 Brandon Aubrey PK 10 161.83 118 195 205
# 2 Ka'Imi Fairbairn PK 6 188.00 170 210 329
# 3 Jake Bates PK 8 191.00 163 236 258
# 4 Cameron Dicker PK 12 194.17 146 277 251
# 5 Harrison Butker PK 10 203.67 164 242 294
# 6 Jake Elliott PK 9 208.83 161 250 308
# 7 Chase McLaughlin PK 9 209.50 179 279 285
# 8 Wil Lutz PK 12 210.20 177 258 510
# 9 Chris Boswell PK 5 210.67 187 246 327
# 10 Jason Sanders PK 12 219.00 185 265 591
# 11 Tyler Bass PK 7 219.67 182 249 331
# 12 Matt Gay PK 12 220.00 157 281 319
# 13 Fairbairn Ka'Imi PK 6 253.00 253 253 -
# 14 Greg Zuerlein PK 9 255.00 255 255 -
# 15 Evan McPherson PK 10 265.00 186 456 526
# 16 Younghoe Koo PK 5 268.80 151 463 495
# 17 Tyler Loop (R) PK 7 282.33 191 489 322
# 18 Daniel Carlson PK 8 298.20 209 478 371
# 19 Joshua Karty PK 8 299.20 208 464 489
# 20 Cam Little PK 8 314.80 184 497 505
# 21 Justin Tucker PK . 316.00 279 353 638
# 22 Will Reichard PK 6 318.00 233 457 569
# 23 Jason Myers PK 8 318.40 248 468 542
# 24 Brandon McManus PK 5 321.50 168 480 524
# 25 Cairo Santos PK 5 343.75 190 503 593
# 26 Chad Ryland PK 8 351.25 214 515 -
# 27 Jake Moody PK 14 374.33 273 499 535
# 28 Blake Grupe PK 11 381.67 248 491 429
# 29 Matt Prater PK . 393.00 393 393 -
# 30 Graham Gano PK 14 399.00 257 507 421