We really don't permit smoking in the office, so we sent 'Mickey The Crab' out on the street to round-up the collectiveopinion of the 2025 fantasy football community. Despite having generally poor interpersonal skills, Mickey did an admirable job of conversing with most of the fantasy experts he metup with and we are happy to present his findings here in the Top 200 'Man on the Street' Consensus Rankings.
OverallQB OnlyRB OnlyWR OnlyTE OnlyPK OnlyDEF Only

2025 Top 200 Expert Consensus Rankings QB Only -August 31, 2025

Rank Team Position Bye
Week
Average
Ranking
Highest
Ranking
Lowest
Ranking
# 1 Lamar Jackson QB 7 25.57 20 31 18
# 2 Josh Allen QB 7 26.14 25 28 17
# 3 Jayden Daniels QB 12 30.71 23 37 27
# 4 Jalen Hurts QB 9 34.43 28 42 32
# 5 Joe Burrow QB 10 48.86 39 64 29
# 6 Patrick Mahomes QB 10 74.43 62 96 49
# 7 Bo Nix QB 12 86.71 69 122 68
# 8 Baker Mayfield QB 9 87.00 63 119 55
# 9 Kyler Murray QB 8 94.57 76 128 79
# 10 Brock Purdy QB 14 100.57 85 152 85
# 11 Caleb Williams QB 5 108.57 93 137 105
# 12 Justin Fields QB 9 111.29 92 128 109
# 13 Justin Herbert QB 12 113.14 92 166 103
# 14 Drake Maye QB 14 115.71 87 171 112
# 15 Dak Prescott QB 10 120.29 78 185 87
# 16 Jared Goff QB 8 130.71 106 192 91
# 17 Jordan Love QB 5 134.43 109 186 119
# 18 JJ McCarthy QB 6 136.43 113 207 124
# 19 Trevor Lawrence QB 8 137.00 86 198 134
# 20 CJ Stroud QB 6 150.14 113 213 114
# 21 Tua Tagovailoa QB 12 174.86 138 245 150
# 22 Cameron Ward (R) QB 10 176.67 132 216 161
# 23 Geno Smith QB 8 180.00 145 223 169
# 24 Matthew Stafford QB 8 180.50 144 226 160
# 25 Bryce Young QB 14 182.20 134 271 162
# 26 Michael Penix QB 5 187.17 143 252 155
# 27 Sam Darnold QB 8 206.00 172 263 184
# 28 Aaron Rodgers QB 5 211.80 184 233 181
# 29 Daniel Jones QB 11 230.00 183 280 206
# 30 Russell Wilson QB 14 251.00 211 306 242
# 31 Anthony Richardson QB 11 263.40 213 284 237
# 32 Jaxson Dart (R) QB 14 264.75 182 307 224
# 33 Joe Flacco QB 9 272.00 212 311 252
# 34 Spencer Rattler QB 11 277.75 236 296 -
# 35 Tyler Shough (R) QB 11 280.00 237 314 295
# 36 Jalen Milroe (R) QB 8 312.67 259 340 291
# 37 Shedeur Sanders (R) QB 9 341.33 310 389 245
# 38 Jameis Winston QB 14 343.00 318 368 -
# 39 Kenny Pickett QB 8 346.00 287 405 -
# 40 Tyrod Taylor QB 9 369.00 337 401 -
# 41 Dillon Gabriel (R) QB 9 369.33 333 416 -
# 42 Will Levis QB 10 392.00 392 392 -
# 43 Kirk Cousins QB 5 392.33 304 517 318
# 44 Sam Howell QB 9 408.50 331 486 -
# 45 Mason Rudolph QB 5 410.00 397 423 -
# 46 Tanner McKee QB 9 411.00 411 411 -
# 47 Malik Willis QB 5 414.00 390 438 -
# 48 Cooper Rush QB 7 415.00 415 415 -
# 49 Kyle Allen QB 8 417.00 417 417 -
# 50 Jimmy Garoppolo QB 8 422.50 362 483 -
# 51 Deshaun Watson QB 9 439.00 439 439 -
# 52 Zach Wilson QB 12 441.00 424 458 -
# 53 Will Grier QB 10 443.00 443 443 -
# 54 Marcus Mariota QB 12 447.50 422 473 -
# 55 Nick Mullens QB 8 450.00 450 450 -
# 56 Joe Milton QB 10 461.00 412 510 -
# 57 Aidan O'Connell QB 8 474.50 463 486 -
# 58 Will Howard (R) QB 5 478.00 478 478 -
# 59 Mac Jones QB 14 484.50 477 492 -
# 60 Gardner Minshew QB 10 487.00 487 487 -